I have spent a substantial part of my life trying to figure it out. I started out as a legal scholar and lawyer working on antitrust, right in the middle of the glorious Chicago School era. I watched lawyers dropping like flies, and I could not quite understand why. What was going on? How had these so called "competition economists" suddenly become the ultimate arbiters of what competition law should be? So, to get to the bottom of it, I went off and did a PhD in economics in Germany. A rather substantial investment just to answer one question.
What I discovered, however, was that Chicago School economics was only one particular brand of economics. A brand that, among other problems, had managed to convince almost everyone (judges included, one Florida conference at a time) that, unless you had a model demonstrating something, you did not really have an argument. My objection is not to models as such. It is to treating models almost as sacred texts, while overlooking the assumptions about how the world works (and especially, should work - ideologically) on which they are built. And those assumptions are very often profoundly wrong/misleading/horrifying.
I think we need to reconsider much more radically how we understand "markets," competition and the objectives of competition law for a society worth living in. We need different ways of assessing whether our economic systems are functioning well, whether good innovation is genuinely being encouraged, and whether consumers and citizens are benefiting.
So, after all these years, my answer is that economics can be a useful tool, at times. But confusing one particular and largely discredited brand of economics (outside the inner circles of friendly competition academics and consultancies) with science (and "truth") itself has been one of the more consequential intellectual mistakes (aka *achievements* by the malicious actors out there) in the history of competition law.
Looking forward to hearing from Helena on this exact topic very soon, up in the Italian Alps!


No comments:
Post a Comment